African American Civil Rights

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #16154
    drjakegb
    Member

    Please address any or all of of the following:

    -To what extent were advances in African-American civil rights the result of grassroots, local initiative?

    -To what extent did they result from the activities of national organizations?

    -To what extent were they the result of government actions?

    -Which of these three mattered the most?

    I thank all posters in advance!

    #16155
    gutzmank
    Participant

    Each of these questions is the subject of bookshelves of dissertations, scholarly articles, and books.

    In a sense, they all require us to engage in alternative history–that is, historical fiction–to come to answers.

    As I understand it, Brown v. Board of Education–result of the NAACP LDF’s legal strategy and extremely partisan behavior by numerous federal judges–spurred private activism, which itself ultimately brought segregation to Americans’ TV screens and led to adoption of the decisive VRA of 1965. That’s what ended segregation, not the 1964 CRA.

    Each of the three had a role. There’s no way to know what would have happened without any of them. In general, however, it was Congress that ended segregation. Historians today tend to resist this conclusion, because they want to stress black agency–just as they want women to be responsible for women’s suffrage, even though of course it was all-male legislatures that adopted the amendment at the behest of all-male electorates in nearly all the states.

    #16156
    woods
    Participant

    I would add that polling data indicates that racial attitudes among the public were liberalizing from the 1940s on.

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.